Create intermediate Works with: Any AI

Title and Thumbnail Concept Scorer

Rubric scoring Has example

Compare ideas before you produce them.

The Open buttons send the prompt text as currently shown below to that site only when you click. Fill in the placeholders first.

Score title and thumbnail ideas for my channel about [CHANNEL_TOPIC]. Audience: [AUDIENCE]. My past top performers and their titles: [TOP_PERFORMERS]. My ideas: [TITLE_THUMBNAIL_IDEAS].

Create a rubric table. For each idea, score 1 to 5 on: clarity (a stranger understands the topic in two seconds), curiosity (creates a question without lying), promise matches content, relevance to the audience's problem, visual simplicity (one idea, readable at phone size), contrast between title and thumbnail (they should add information, not repeat), uniqueness against what is already out there, and risk of being misleading.

Show total scores and ranking. For the top three, write improved title variants (three each, under 60 characters) and a thumbnail description with the focal subject, the text (max 4 words), color contrast, and what to avoid.

Add a testing plan: how to compare two options (for example by using the platform's test feature or by changing after 48 hours) and what metric to read (click-through rate with impressions caution). Never recommend deceptive tactics. Ask which idea I would be proud to see on a stranger's screen.

Fill in before use

Optional: type your details and the prompt above updates. Nothing is saved or sent.

Replace each bracketed placeholder with your own details, then paste into Any AI or another assistant.

Idea | Clarity | Curiosity | Promise match | Relevance | Simplicity | Complement | Uniqueness | Honesty risk | Total
A: "I Tried 5 Budget Apps" + face and phone | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | low | 28/35
B: "Budgeting Is Broken" + red cross | 3 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 5 | 2 | 4 | high (overpromise) | 24/35
Improved titles for A: "5 Budget Apps Tested: The Winner Surprised Me" | "I Tried 5 Budget Apps for 30 Days".
Thumbnail A: face on left, phone right showing a green number, text "30 DAYS" (2 words), high contrast.
Test plan: compare two titles with the platform's test feature or a 48-hour swap; read click-through rate with impressions caution.

• titles